White paper
The Elop Insight technique
for non-destructive testing of concrete structures
White paper by:
Prof. Dr. Bjorn Taljsten, Invator
December, 2020
Introduction
Our modern society is strongly dependent on well-functioning transport infrastructure, including roads, rail, water, and air. Besides this, we expect a reliable energy supply and long-lasting buildings. The most commonly used material for ground infrastructure is reinforced concrete, and this trend will continue.
Even though concrete is so common, it is susceptible to different kinds of deterioration processes and defects as a consequence of improperly controlled production or construction processes, environmental conditions, cement composition, pollution, and surrounding infrastructure. Examples of damages these defects may lead to are cracking, reinforcement bond loss, voids, reduction of the cover layer thickness, corrosion, and delamination.
In the long run, if existing problems remain unaddressed, they lower the performance level of the structure and may eventually lead to unsafe structures or even fatal accidents. Preventing that necessitates methods for regular assessment of the structural integrity to avoid problems that may shorten service life.
Maintenance of the asset can not only be planned, but also repairs and interventions can be precisely targeted and localized, retaining structural integrity and extending lifetime whilst at the same time ensuring the structure fully fulfils safety requirements. This has noticeable economic as well as environmental implications.
It is also important to mention that the construction industry is responsible for up to 40% of global energy consumption as well as up to 40% of all waste creation. Within the next ten years, the demand for global construction is expected to increase by 70%. In light of these numbers, many have been looking for ways to move the industry in a more sustainable direction.
For a long time, our economy has had an open-ended setup with a linear material flow. In such a traditional setup, raw materials are utilized to make a product which at the end of its service life is disposed of and thrown away. In the case of concrete materials, this often ends up as construction debris with landfill as the main application.
In a circular economy model, where extending lifetime and avoiding waste are the main assumptions, all materials are conserved and used as input for new products. For existing concrete infrastructure, this implies maintaining and prolonging lifecycle, rather than replacing with new builds when safety and design standards are in place.
Traditionally, understanding the health condition of concrete structures has been limited to visual inspections or coring. Visual inspection only reveals the surface, while coring is expensive, time-consuming, and weakens the structure. NDT assessment offers a better path, but many techniques remain complicated, time-consuming or difficult to interpret.
Only some techniques provide 3D visualization of the interior structure, and the recent development of smartphone technology together with overall digitalization has made productive workflows more feasible.
Figure 1: Linear vs. circular economy.
The foundation of deterioration
The most commonly used technologies in concrete construction for long span lengths, such as bridges, or for thin slabs, are reinforced concrete and pre-stressed concrete. In both cases, strengthening is done with the implementation of steel elements: reinforcement with steel rods in the former and tendons in the latter.
A decrease in strength, and therefore maximum carried load, is generally caused by deterioration of the concrete material or corrosion of the steel elements. There are numerous reasons for aging of concrete constructions, such as construction faults, conditions of usage, quality of materials, and environmental conditions.
These conditions can be roughly divided into mechanical, chemical, and physical factors, for example fatigue, impact, overload, alkali silica reactions, shrinkage, and freeze-thaw cycles. Corrosion in steel is most often related to carbonation of concrete or chloride introduced corrosion due to de-icing salts or salts from the ocean.
Defects emerging on the surface can be easily identified by visual inspection, but the flaws inside a structure need more advanced methods to be revealed.
The importance of assessment
A structure is built with a fundamental performance requirement for a minimum period, as defined by the client. Performance can be related to structural safety, load carrying capacity, serviceability, durability and more. Over time the structure might degrade and eventually reach the lowest acceptable performance where repair is needed.
The remaining life of the repaired structure depends on life strategies, budget, but also on correct assessment. Choosing the wrong repair measure or basing the strategy on inferior assessment can even make the life of the repaired structure very short.
Concrete structures, and in particular bridges, need to be inspected regularly to meet the safety and accessibility requirements of users. To be the most efficient from a client and cost perspective, assessment should guide maintenance, repair and strengthening strategy.
Even though there is no single standard procedure that every NDT inspector should follow, the usual assessment strategy should follow a three-level principle.
Besides the investigation of chemical composition that enables us to conclude the degree of erosion, it is important to scrutinize the interior of the structure for the sake of comprehensive understanding.
The usual assessment strategy should follow the three-level principle:
- Level 1 comprises a simple visual inspection carried out from the ground, boat, or at easily accessible places. You investigate concrete surfaces and measure carbonation depth and concrete cover.
- Level 2, so-called extended analysis, includes a detailed visual inspection of all concrete surfaces, as well as some measurements and material tests. In addition to level 1, chloride content, crack widths, delamination and condition of reinforcement should be investigated.
- Level 3 foresees an extensive analysis that includes the same type of measurements and tests as for level 2, but more samples are collected, and often also NDT inspections are carried out to a larger extent.
It is recommended that the NDT procedure includes all three levels, as it can extend the understanding of possible problems, needs, or safety measures that should be applied. It is also good practice to schedule an NDT inspection calendar for preventive maintenance.
Methodology and equipment
Elop's vision is to provide asset owners with smart products and solutions that help improve safety, extend lifetime, minimize lifecycle cost, and contribute to an overall reduction in the environmental footprint of concrete structures globally.
As the built infrastructure gets older, the need for thorough assessment and understanding of deterioration process and its influence on building safety increases. The basis for efficient lifecycle management is to know its status, what is managed, whether the facility meets safety requirements, and what it costs to remedy identified problems.
In particular, for concrete structures, such information is not possible to gain without in-depth NDT evaluation. Elop has developed a new groundbreaking solution enabling accurate inspection, asset management, and structural health monitoring of concrete structures - the Elop Insight.
The Elop Insight scanner rolls over the surface to be investigated, and a 3D scan of the interior structure is generated in real-time. Thanks to ultrasonic technology, it can accurately identify the size and depth of existing defects within concrete structures including voids, honeycombs, delamination, air pockets, and internal cracking.
The methodology follows a typical assessment procedure, but is characterized by significantly shorter time-to-result whilst maintaining higher accuracy compared to other techniques and methods supported by devices available on the market.
While the scanner rolls over the surface, ultrasonic waves are sent through the material, reflected at the interfaces between the concrete and empty spaces within the structure, and received back by the receiving transducers. With the use of the Synthetic Aperture Focusing Technique, the 3D live image of the interior structure is reconstructed.
Immediate cloud sharing capabilities allow for remote team support when needed. A fully digital workflow eliminates unnecessary manual steps, increasing productivity, efficiency, and completeness of the overall process.
The strong focus of the Elop team has been to deliver the best thought through and most pragmatic solution for NDT inspections, bringing a series of advantages that make Elop Insight a solution of unparalleled effectiveness.
The following can be listed among the most important advantages.
Easy to handle
Elop Insight scanner is a rolling device, therefore requiring minimum physical effort to handle, no matter how the scanned surface is located. Its ergonomic design allows precise data gathering with minimal exposure to errors resulting from the human factor, and immediate 3D visualization gives prompt feedback from the scanning process.
Software designed to be simple to use and intuitive allows short time-to-results and short time-to-legitimate-results. All gathered data is transferred and stored in the cloud automatically, simplifying the post-inspection part of the process by removing unnecessary steps such as manual data transfer or backup.
Efficient
As every minute counts, Elop designed the scanner to be the most efficient and pragmatic solution available. The ergonomics of Elop Insight allow the inspector to scan large areas effortlessly with relatively high speed, focusing only on areas that need to be scrutinized in more detail.
Immediate 3D visualisation improves decision making and gathering of the most meaningful and valuable data. The cloud-based web portal gives access to data from anytime and anywhere, making offsite analysis, conclusions and report generation significantly more efficient.
Removing interruptions from the inspection, simplifying it, and minimizing the chance for human-induced error, make the overall process time-efficient and pragmatic. The device is also designed with care for robustness, dust and water protection, and a substantial operating temperature range.
Live 3D models at hand
One of the invaluable advantages of Elop Insight is live 3D visualisation of the concrete structure. The SAFT algorithm gives a strong visualisation perspective, revealing areas of interest, while filters and multiple views support step-by-step analysis and precise conclusions.
Data clarity
The great challenge lies in properly visualising data and obtaining a meaningful, geometrically correct representation of the internal structure. The adaptation of the visualization algorithm gives assurance of data clarity, while the scanner's built-in quality mechanisms maximize reliable data and minimize the outputs that need to be manually controlled during inspection work.
Pressure sensors in the handles provide feedback when the contact pressure between scanner and surface is too low. Calibration and rolling-speed feedback further assure that gathered data is not lost or compromised in quality. This fully digital workflow not only shortens time-to-data but also removes elements of the process that are prone to human inattention.
Given the productivity achieved due to the rolling principle and high-speed scanning, it becomes possible to inspect nearly 100% of the asset area, improving the probability of detecting suspicious areas that can then be rescanned in high-resolution mode.
Fast and professional backup and support
The team of engineers, scientists, application specialists, and service engineers in Elop's customer satisfaction center brings comprehensive support whenever it is needed. Elop is committed both to improvement of construction sustainability and to making sure Elop solutions are sustainable for customers too.
Any minute spent offsite counts, and Elop is committed to making that time efficient through software, support and streamlined workflows.
Reference projects
Voids and delamination on a wall structure. An assessment of precast element working as formwork for in situ cast concrete was carried out after a larger void had been found when drilling was made for fasteners.
In the assessment, the following methodology was followed:
- Overall visual inspection studying of documents and planning
- Simple investigation with both Impact Echo and Ultra Pulse Echo to calibrate and investigate best strategies
- Dividing areas into sufficient small squares, but not too small due to time limitations. Here 250 x 250 mm was a good compromise
- Using Impact Echo to detect possible flaws in the concrete elements
- Using Elop Insight for more detailed investigation
- Verifying results with Endoscope
In total 85% of 3,000 m2 wall area was examined.
Large areas were found with delamination or honeycombing between the precast elements and the in-situ cast concrete. However, the size of the defects was small and the existing steel reinforcement was to a major extent covered by concrete. The reason for debonding was most likely ice in the formwork, shrinkage of the in-situ concrete, temperature effects, or a combination of these factors.
Conclusion
The newly developed ultrasound scanner and cloud-based software, Elop Insight, is one of the most advanced and versatile devices on the market, allowing users to detect and visualise air pockets and voids within concrete structures.
Here are a couple of points that need to be stressed:
- Such a high-tech, future-orientated device will not replace the expertise, knowledge, and hard work that every NDT inspector puts into the job. It helps make the work more efficient, comprehensive, and meaningful.
- Every asset inspection still needs a multi-angular, comprehensive approach, but using Elop Insight it can be optimized, focusing on correct diagnosis whilst minimizing time and effort on auxiliary activities such as reporting and data organization.
- NDT inspection is invaluable for built infrastructure and needs to be esteemed by the knowledge and expertise, not the hours spent onsite. Elop is committed to improving productivity at every possible step through smart software solutions.
- Elop Insight simplifies the overall assessment. NDT evaluation may be complex, but it does not have to be complicated. The direct 3D live visualisation of the interior structure helps data interpretation and productivity.
- As one size does not fit all, one technology will not be the answer to everything. However, Elop Insight is proven to be unmatched when it comes to the detection and visualisation of voids, air pockets, or honeycombing within the concrete structure.
Convenient and well-thought-through cloud data storage with access through the web portal interface makes it a strong tool not only for one asset but as part of a broader asset management system.
Summarising, bulletproof technology incorporated into a bulletproof solution allows users to get bulletproof data leading to bulletproof conclusions.
Key takeaways
- It is not always possible to build better for longer lifespan, but it is possible to extend asset lifecycle through diligent monitoring, regular checks, and preventive maintenance planning. Novel inspection solutions such as Elop Insight provide reliable data and an optimized digital workflow that revolutionizes productivity.
- Immediate 3D visualisation and the rolling principle of the scanner together with a fully digital workflow make the Elop Insight solution revolutionary, transforming the NDT inspection market segment and making it a central assessment technology rather than a sporadic supportive one.
- Given the amount of data collected while scanning, and the way it is stored, Elop Insight is a strong starting point for preventive maintenance and health monitoring not only for a specific asset but also as a predictive statistical mechanism for other assets and observed deterioration mechanisms.
Sources
- Global status report for buildings and construction, 2019
- ResearchGate, 2019
- PWC Global Construction 2025, 2018
- Circular economy in the Nordic construction sector, 2018
Request demo
Want to learn more about Elop Insight and how the scanner supports concrete assessment and maintenance?